Too Committed to Fail? Credible Revisability and the Strategic Orchestration of Nusantara, New Capitals and Megaprojects under Radical Uncertainty

Authors

  • Rozali Indra Saputra Universitas Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55324/josr.v5i12.3584

Keywords:

strategic commitment, escalation of commitment, megaprojects, new capital cities, ecosystem orchestration

Abstract

Between 2023 and 2026, several high-profile megaprojects underwent cancellation, scope reductions, funding withdrawals, or organizational restructuring. Existing theoretical perspectives explain why project sponsors escalate their commitments, why megaprojects experience cost overruns, how real options generate strategic value, and how orchestrators coordinate actors beyond their direct organizational control. However, these perspectives do not adequately explain how sponsors can maintain credible long-term commitments while preserving the legitimate capacity to revise strategic decisions under radical uncertainty. This article develops a theory of credible revisability by integrating insights from strategic commitment, escalation of commitment, megaproject governance, real options theory, ecosystem orchestration, public-sector dynamic capabilities, and mission-oriented innovation policy. The theoretical synthesis is supported by a comparative documentary analysis of twelve megaprojects and new capital city initiatives. The study identifies commitment displacement—the shift of commitment from enduring public functions toward specific implementation instruments—as a central mechanism through which strategic commitment can evolve into institutional entrenchment. Building on this mechanism, the article introduces Transformational Orchestration for Nexus Endurance (TONE), a governance strategy that anchors long-term commitments in a protected minimum level of essential public functions, establishes predefined authority to revise implementation instruments, distributes decision-making rights over strategic options among actors controlling complementary resources, manages interdependencies across interconnected systems, and applies symmetrical evaluation criteria to decisions concerning project continuation and termination. Eight theoretical propositions, a governance typology, and tests against competing theoretical explanations specify the conditions under which TONE is expected to outperform institutional entrenchment, strategic drift, and opportunistic policy reversal. Indonesia's new capital, Ibu Kota Nusantara (IKN), serves as an illustrative case demonstrating the framework's applicability and potential transferability to other new capital cities, planned urban developments, and large-scale infrastructure megaprojects.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-19