The Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict: Between the Validity of Norms and the Effectiveness of International Law

Authors

  • Imam Khalid Al Azis Universitas Islam Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55324/josr.v5i12.3574

Keywords:

Legal Positivism, H.L.A. Hart, Normative Validity, International Humanitarian Law, Gaza

Abstract

The Gaza conflict raises a fundamental theoretical question concerning the gap between the legal validity of international humanitarian law (IHL) norms and their effectiveness in protecting civilians during armed conflict. This study aims to examine the legal foundations of normative validity and the limitations of legal positivism, particularly H. L. A. Hart's legal theory, in explaining the implementation and enforcement of international humanitarian law. Employing a normative legal research methodology, the study adopts statutory, conceptual, and case-based approaches through an examination of relevant international humanitarian law instruments, reports issued by the United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, and official documents of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Criminal Court (ICC). The findings demonstrate that the legal validity of international humanitarian law norms derives from recognized sources of international law and is not automatically diminished or extinguished by violations or failures of compliance. Hart's concepts of primary rules, secondary rules, and the rule of recognition provide a theoretical framework for understanding the structure, identification, and operation of legal norms; however, their application to the decentralized international legal system requires careful contextual interpretation. Furthermore, the effectiveness of civilian protection depends not only on the existence of legally binding norms but also on state and non-state actor compliance, enforcement mechanisms, international cooperation, and institutional capacity. The study concludes that normative validity constitutes a necessary legal foundation for civilian protection but does not, by itself, guarantee the effective implementation or enforcement of international humanitarian law during armed conflict.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-19