JOSR: Journal of Social Research
Januari 2022, 1 (2), 138-150
p-ISSN: 2827-9832 e-ISSN: xxxx-xxxx
Available online at http:// https://ijsr.internationaljournallabs.com/index.php/ijsr
http://ijsr.internationaljournallabs.com/index.php/ijsr
SPREADING THE CHARM OF 'FEELINGS OF THE
PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION' THROUGH TIKTOK AHEAD
OF THE NAHDLATUL ULAMA CONGRESS
Rachmat Hidayat
University of Indonesia
rachmat.hidayat01@ui.ac.id
Abstrak (indonesia)
Received:24
Desember
2021
Revised :29
Desember
2021
Accepted:09
Januari
2022
Penelitian dilakukan dengan mengamati dua calon ketua
umum Pengurus Besar Nahdlatul Ulama (PBNU), masing-
masing KH Said Aqil Siraj (Kiai Said) dan Yahya Cholil
Staquf atau Gus Yahya dalam menerapkan strategi
marketing politik melalui media sosial TikTok. Semua data
observasi dikumpulkan dari awal bulan, hingga 20
Desember 2021, menjelang Kongres ke-34 di Provinsi
Lampung. Observasi dilakukan dengan teknik etnografi,
dianalisis dengan metode penelitian kualitatif. Saluran
media sosial TikTok merupakan bagian dari perubahan
perilaku masyarakat di era digitalisasi saat ini. Hal itu juga
dilakukan Kiai Said dan Gus Yahya, dua calon ketua umum
PBNU dalam demokrasi di ruang digital. Saling menebar
pesona, serupa dengan pertarungan Pemilihan Presiden
(Pilpres) dalam menyampaikan pesan kepada publik atau
warga, termasuk warga Nahdliyin. Muktamar ke-34 kali ini
rentan terhadap kepentingan politik pada 2024. Apalagi NU
sebagai ormas terbesar di Indonesia sangat seksi dan
diperhitungkan oleh para aktor politik yang akan bertarung
di Pilpres mendatang.
Kata kunci: Era Digital; TikTok; Pemasaran Politik,
Nahdlatul Ulama; Demokrasi.
Abstract (English)
The research was conducted by observing two candidates
for the general chairmanship of the Nahdlatul Ulama
Executive Board (PBNU), each KH Said Aqil Siraj (Kiai
Said) and Yahya Cholil Staquf or Gus Yahya in
implementing political marketing strategies through
TikTok social media. All observation data were collected
from the beginning of the month, until December 20, 2021,
ahead of the 34th Congress in Lampung Province.
Observations were made using ethnographic techniques,
analyzed by qualitative research methods. The TikTok
social media channel is part of changing people's behavior
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 139
in the current digitalization era. This was also done to
Kiai Said and Gus Yahya, two candidates for the general
chairmanship of PBNU in democracy in the digital space.
Spreading mutual charm, similar to the battle for the
Presidential Election (Pilpres) in conveying messages to
the public or citizens, including Nahdliyin residents. The
34th congress this time is vulnerable to political interests
in 2024. Moreover, NU as the largest mass organization in
Indonesia is sexy and highly calculated by political actors
who will fight in the upcoming presidential election.
Keywords: Digital Age; TikTok; Political Marketing,
Nahdlatul Ulama; Democracy.
*Correspondent Author : Rachmat Hidayat
Email : rachmat.hidayat01@ui.ac.id
INTRODUCTION
Technological innovations that accompany the development of the times
and continue to this day. Creating a pattern of community participation that also
changes, accelerating an idea, democracy, or simply an idea that is fed to the
public through digital media channels which are now increasingly diverse.
Including the TikTok social media channel, which indulges the public in
interacting in the digital space. Manuel Castells, a figure who studies the
development of information technology, revealed that today's society has
transformed into a network society (Manovich, 2003). The digitalization of
communication networks is the backbone of the network society. Network society
manifests itself in various forms, according to culture, institutions, with their
respective backgrounds in this era (Castells & Cardoso, 2005). The formation of a
network society whose social structure is created and activated by information
processed digitally. A social structure whose infrastructure is based on digital
networks has the potential capacity to become global (Barney, 2004). He
emphasized network power refers to the power of actors and organizations
included in the network which is the core of the global network society of human
collectives or individuals. (Castells, 2016).
While democracy is a form of the rights of all citizens, participate in
discussions in making a decision. Democracy also provides a space that covers all
aspects of life in all social conditions that develop in society, including the digital
space utilizing existing social media channels. In the economic sector, as well as
in culture in the current era of digitalization.
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 140
A democracy that can also be interpreted as justice. In the political
context, democracy is defined as the practice of freedom of expression freely and
equally. The main principle in a democracy is that its people can openly, freely
express their aspirations in every political and social policy. The principle
becomes the starting point in exercising freedom of expression in a country
(Balkin, 2004). Network society in today's digital era, which causes not only
individuals, but community organizations, inevitably have to enter into it. This
includes Nahdlatul Ulama (NU), the largest Islamic organization in Indonesia
which is also part of a networked group or society in utilizing its democratic
rights in the digital space. It is unavoidable, during the contest for the chair of the
general chairman, the largest religious organization in the republic utilizes the
digital space as a place for democracy, implementing its political marketing
strategy with the hope of approval from the public and the nahdliyin (Turmudi,
2006).
The marketing concept that was originally used with the business
objective of competing to market products, is now a marketing concept that is
applied in politics(Rafiq & Ahmed, 2000). Politics is also understood as a
separate institution but interacts with, media including social media (Schwanholz,
Graham, & Stoll, 2018). Mainstream media and online media (social media) are
increasingly difficult to separate as time goes by to integrate into the digital space.
Marketing strategies was also caused by a shift in the way to recruit constituents,
which initially used conventional methods, such as campaigns in the open field,
motorized vehicle parades, to impassioned speeches by campaigners (jurkam). In
line with changes in the socio-technological environment, politicians, community
organizations including figures, artists, and public figures, use social media as a
campaign event. Want to reach and convince the public as much as possible
through the digital space in implementing marketing strategies, including political
marketing
TikTok
TikTok social media is now also a place for democracy as well as
marketing political marketing strategies between candidates. Not only young
people, but TikTok is also spreading the 'virus' to those who are old or aged. The
battle ahead of the 43rd PBNU Executive Conference held in Bandar Lampung
City, Lampung Province, one of these digital media channels has become an arena
for political marketing strategies against candidates in the race for the chair of the
PBNU general chair. Strategize each other, to get support in the digital space. is
increasing. In 2020 TikTok became the most downloaded digital media
worldwide (Rowe & SHRM-CPWinona Area, 2021). Digital media TikTok also
known as lip-sync application ( lip-sync ) until now is at the peak of its fame. This
video-based application has received a lot of attention from young people.
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 141
TikTok logo image. (Named, 2021)
Before the digital media TikTok existed, in January 2009 one of the digital
media Facebook was already global first. At that time, Facebook had more than
175 users worldwide. And at the same time, every minute of the ten hours various
content is uploaded through another digital media channel, namely YouTube.
Research conducted by Forrester, almost 75 percent of social media users surf the
internet in the second quarter of 2008 (Haenlein & Kaplan, 2010). Both define
social media as an internet-based group that allows the creation and exchange of
content between users. Each individual can feed, create an idea then connect to the
internet. And data processors designed by humans for certain reasons, under
certain conditions create cognition. This later became a social activity. Social
media is a complex term with multiple meanings (Fuchs, 2014).
In 2020, becoming a global trend in the country, the non-gaming
application TikTok was the second most downloaded application in 2019.
Namely, there were 1.5 billion downloads on the App Store and Google Play. The
official Tiktok account TikTok official Indonesia released, the digital media
channel based in Beijing, known as Bytedance, Indonesia is ranked fourth in the
world, with around 30.7 million users (Patel & Binjola, 2020). The extraordinary
popularity of TikTok has become the latest platform for voicing political
aspirations. As many as 49% of teenagers use the Tiktok platform. Interestingly,
parents have started to join and use Tiktok during the Covid-19 pandemic
(Bairizki et al., 2021). TikTok is also not just for entertainment and a democratic
arena but is also used as a propaganda channel. Preachers have a TikTok account,
produce short videos to convey religious knowledge and da'wah in a more
attractive form so that they get high views and enter FYP ( For Your Page ).
(Named, 2021).
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 142
Nahlatul Ulama (NU)
Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) Organization Logo
The largest Islamic organization in Indonesia was formed on January 31,
1926, to represent the traditional ulama. This teaching is sourced from the Qur'an,
Sunnah, Ijma (decision of the scholars earlier). (Wikipedia). (Machfudz) released
the founding figures of NU, among others; KH Hasyim Asy'ari, KH Bisri
Syamsuri, KH Abdullah Wahab Chasbullah, KH Abdul Chamid Faqih, KH
Ridwan Abdullah 1884-1962. Then KH Abdullah Halim Leuwemunding, Abdul
Aziz, Surabaya, KH Ma'shum, KH A Dachlan Achjad, KH Nachrowi Thahir, KH
R Asnawi, Sheikh Ganaim, KH Abdullah. In addition, several well-known figures
are behind the scenes, namely KH Kholil Bangkalan who incidentally is a teacher
of KH Hasyim Asy'ari, and KH As'ad who became his fellow teacher when he
was a student at KH Khalil (Ismail, 2011).
Political guidelines for NU citizens. (NU online)
1. Politics for Nahdlatul Ulama means the involvement of citizens in the life of
the nation and state as a whole in accordance with Pancasila and the 1945
Constitution.
2. Politics for Nahdlatul Ulama is politics that has a national perspective and
leads to national integration with steps that always uphold unity and integrity
to achieve common goals, namely the realization of a just and prosperous
society physically and mentally and carried out as a charity of worship
towards happiness in the world. this world and the life in the hereafter.
3. Politics for Nahdlatul Ulama is the development of essential and democratic
values of independence, educating the nation's maturity to realize the rights,
obligations, and responsibilities to achieve the common good.
4. Politics for Nahdlatul Ulama must be carried out with morals, ethics, and
culture that believes in the Almighty God has just and civilized humanity
upholds the unity of Indonesia, is a populist led by wisdom in
deliberation/representation, and social justice for all Indonesian people.
5. Politics for Nahdlatul Ulama must be carried out with honesty of conscience
and religious morals, constitutional, fair in accordance with agreed rules and
norms, and can develop a deliberation mechanism in solving common
problem
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 143
6. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
7. This study seeks to show a democratic process, the application of political
marketing strategies through TikTok carried out by two candidates for the
general chairman of the Nahdlatul Ulama Executive Board (PBNU). Both
are incumbent KH Said Aqil Siraj. This NU figure from Cirebon, who is
often called Kang Said, has served as chairman of the PBNU twice and is
eager to run again as a candidate. His competitor, the former spokesman
for the 14th President KH Abdurrahman Wahid or Gus Dur, Yahya
Staquf. The politician who now serves as Head of the PBNU Aam, often
called Gus Yahya, declared himself to be advancing and hoped to get
support from all parties, including the political elite.
8. Both Kang Said and Gus Yahya are marketed through political marketing
strategies through social media TikTok. Democracy through digital space
ahead of the fight which will be held in Bandar Lampung City, Lampung
Province, at the 34th PBNU Congress this year
9.
Hunt, (Henneberg & O’Shaughnessy, 2009) explain, political marketing is
an interdisciplinary subject of marketing and political science. Political marketing
techniques must be allied with technology, in this case, digital media, to expand
their reach. Not only for the basis of party membership but also to get creative
input in the context of implementing policies. Existing social media, including
TikTok, have become a digital platform for creating new ways of marketing or
campaigning for politics. Become a good new channel for candidates, including
their supporters, to potential voters and to interact. The democratic process seems
inseparable in the implementation of political marketing strategies. Moreover, the
strategy is carried out in the digital space. A marketing concept that was originally
used in the business world, has now penetrated the world of politics which is
currently being facilitated by various forms of digitalization that are growing.
Various digital media, including existing social media, make it easier for the
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 144
political marketing process to be delivered quickly. The era of digitalization has
also shifted public behavior, not only campaigning with the old pattern. The
classical theory of democracy is based on the belief that citizens should be
adequately informed by various information channels. Social interaction is
necessary for fostering respect, trust between different communities (Newman,
1994). In the next era, the political world may give birth to many studies,
including those from academics. The world of progressive politics can present all
possibilities. And actually, the implementation or strategy of political marketing is
nothing new. This application has already been carried out in several countries on
the European and American continents. At the beginning of the 20th century,
America has implemented a political marketing strategy as part of the
consequences of the development of democracy which is growing to this day.
In 1980, political marketing had begun to develop, which was marked by
the conventional channel at that time, television as a channel for delivering
messages to the public. One example of political marketing at that time was when
British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher came to power. Utilizing television and
radio as campaign media. Meanwhile in Indonesia, the implementation of political
marketing has been open since 1998. At that time, it was known as the
reformation era which was accompanied by the emergence of various political
parties (parties) which reached 150 parties (Baines, Crawford, O’Shaughnessy,
Worcester, & Mortimore, 2014).
METHOD
This research is an attempt to find out how democratic practices occur in
implementing political marketing strategies through TikTok social media. In
particular, the activities of two candidates for the general chairmanship of
PBNU, KH Said Aqil Siraj or Kang Said, and Yahya Stafuq are often called Gus
Yahya. Through an online observation approach with the ethnographic method,
with a qualitative research approach. Observations were made at the beginning of
the month until December 20, 2021, or three days before the congress took place.
The ethnographic method that is understood, one of its advantages is
surfing through the internet without being confined by space and time in
observing the object under study. Obtain detailed information as well as apply
intelligence patterns in this research process. Conduct searches without being
known by the subject under study (Miller, Hengst, & Wang, 2003). According to
Jorgen Skageby (Annisa, 2019), online ethnography is a qualitative method in
understanding what is happening in the virtual space in the digitalization era
(Foley, 2020) explained that ethnographic research is qualitative research that
provides space for researchers to describe and interpret the values of behavior
and various forms of communication that are carried out.
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 145
According to (Semiawan, 2010), the purpose of a qualitative approach is
an in-depth search for symptoms or facts that are not seen on the surface. Depth
in revealing a fact characterizes this research which is not may be revealed
without observation. Using a simple definition, qualitative research is
interpretive or interpretive, using many methods in examining what is being
studied. Qualitative researchers usually conduct studies of natural things around
them. Understanding, interpreting the meaning of the things in question (Winter,
2000). Qualitative research also aims to provide a conceptual understanding of
the phenomenon under study. Through qualitative, it can also be used as a place
to refute existing theories. Theories are needed in their capacity to provide
conceptual understanding linked to the research focus. Focused on this research,
by observing the two candidates for the general chairmanship of PBNU. What is
the various information in the form of text, video, or images on the TikTok social
media page ahead of the 34th PBNU Congress in Bandar Lampung City? Both of
them are based on observations made, marketed through a persuasive
communication approach to persuade and influence the public through the digital
space ahead of the 34th PBNU Congress.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
In the observations made on KH Said Aqil Siraj or Kang Said and Yahya
Staquf or Gus Yahya, some information in the form of pictures and videos are
fed through TikTok social media. Political marketing strategy through TikTok is
not carried out through their accounts but is carried out by other account owners,
who then feed the results of the information obtained to the public through
TikTok social media. In the observations made, it was also found that various
texts that were fed through the official PBNU account on TikTok social media
were against both of them.
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 146
Observations were then made through the Tiktok social media account
with the keyword PBNU congress. Two accounts belonging to the nahdliyin,
#nahdlatul_ulama, and #nu_online participated in providing information ahead of
the 34th PBNU Congress which will be held in Lampung Province. The
#nu_online account found text in the form of a video comparing two figures of
the candidate for the general chairmanship of PBNU, Kiai Said or Kang Said and
Gus Yahya. At the beginning of their narration, they began with information that
they both knew NU through their father. The text in the form of a video on
TikTok from the observations made was liked by 2302 netizens and as many as
53 various comments on the text of this video. The information that was fed to
the two candidates for the general chairmanship of PBNU, KH Said Aqil Siraj
and Yahya Cholil Staquf was carried out by implementing a political marketing
strategy. The vision and mission of the two, are similar to the strategy applied
during political battles at the presidential and vice-presidential elections. The
battle of 'election flavors' at the 34th congress this time. The era of democracy in
the digital space, including through social media TikTok, cannot be separated
from it, inevitably being associated with the implementation of a pattern of
political marketing strategies. Although Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) is not a political
organization, the aura of political struggle is felt and often occurs at the PBNU
Congress which is held every five years.
In the current era of digitalization, which allows the political realm to
give birth to many studies. The world of politics is progressive and can give birth
to all kinds of possibilities, combined with ways of communicating to influence
the public through the digital space. With regard to the research conducted, both
Kiai Said and Gus Yahya display charm, both seek the blessing of the nahdliyin,
especially those who vote ahead of the congress. Implementing a political
marketing strategy by feeding ideas in the form of narratives, images, or
uploaded videos. They both want to advance NU to be better, as the largest
Islamic organization in Indonesia, with different narratives, different visions, and
missions but with the same goal. One, Kiai Said wants to retain his seat as
general chairman of PBNU for the third time. Meanwhile, Gus Yahya as the
challenger wants to win the chair of general chairman.
Democratic process that is interpreted by researchers, a freedom to
express opinions is included in the digital space. Determining a choice by linking
a concept of political marketing strategy. Democracy in a thought interpreted by
researchers, freedom to express opinions, voice what they want, including
participating in making political choices as well as implementing political
marketing strategies. Political marketing can help community leaders, including
politicians, in making early detection so that they are efficient and effective
(Habermas, 2006).
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 147
In applying political marketing theory, it is not only about marketing
activities but is integrated into the political environment. This provides an
advantage for the political elite, including supporting netizens, to get targeted
support while implementing political marketing strategies (Henneberg,
Scammell, & O’Shaughnessy, 2009) explains that political marketing strategy is
currently a new way of doing research. His presence encourages the expansion of
space in the application of marketing concepts by political actors, success teams,
bureaucrats, including academics.
Researchers think that the 34th Congress is vulnerable to political
interests in 2024. Moreover, NU as the largest mass organization in Indonesia is
sexy and highly considered by political actors who will fight in the upcoming
presidential election. So it is not surprising that the presidential election air was
so felt at this congress. Although not present in person, and not as a congress
participant, the public is spoiled by the digital space to get information quickly
about the congress held in Bandar Lampung City, Lampung Province.
Technology in the digital era makes it easy for the world community to access
the internet, get information and feed any information in his daily life, including
in democracy. With a high-speed computer network that passes through it in a
virtual space, the public can easily access information channels. View news,
watch videos, listen to music, and hang out with family, friends. ( Straubhaar &
LaRose, 2004).
CONCLUSION
The results of the research conducted, the researcher assumes that the
34th congress this time is vulnerable to political interests in 2024. Moreover, NU
as the largest mass organization in Indonesia is sexy and highly considered by
political actors who will fight in the upcoming presidential election. So it is not
surprising that the presidential election air was so felt at this congress. Although
not present in person, and not as participants in the congress, the public was
spoiled by the digital space to get information quickly about the congress which
was held in Bandar Lampung City, Lampung Province.
REFERENCES
Baines, Paul, Crawford, Ian, O’Shaughnessy, Nicholas, Worcester, Robert, &
Mortimore, Roger. (2014). Positioning in political marketing: How semiotic
analysis adds value to traditional survey approaches. Journal of Marketing
Management, 30(12), 172200.
Bairizki, Ahmad, Irwansyah, Rudy, Arifudin, Opan, Asir, Muhammad, Ganika,
Wijiharta Gerry, Karyanto, Budi, & Lewaherilla, Norisca. (2021).
Manajemen Perubahan. Penerbit Widina.
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 148
Balkin, Jack M. (2004). Digital speech and democratic culture: A theory of
freedom of expression for the information society. NyuL Rev., 79, 1.
Barney, Darin. (2004). The network society (Vol. 2). Polity.
Castells, Manuel. (2016). A sociology of power: My intellectual journey. Annual
Review of Sociology, 42, 119.
Castells, Manuel, & Cardoso, Gustavo. (2005). The network society: From
knowledge to policy. Center for Transatlantic Relations, Paul H. Nitze School
of Advanced ….
Foley, Tunisha. (2020). Talent Retention Strategies for Service Industry Managers
Within Rust Belts. Walden University.
Fuchs, Christian. (2014). Digital Labour and Karl Marx. Routledge.
Habermas, Jürgen. (2006). Political communication in media society: Does
democracy still enjoy an epistemic dimension? The impact of normative
theory on empirical research. Communication Theory, 16(4), 411426.
Haenlein, Michael, & Kaplan, Andreas M. (2010). An empirical analysis of
attitudinal and behavioral reactions toward the abandonment of unprofitable
customer relationships. Journal of Relationship Marketing, 9(4), 200228.
Henneberg, Stephan C., & O’Shaughnessy, Nicholas J. (2009). Political
relationship marketing: Some macro/micro thoughts. Journal of Marketing
Management, 25(12), 529.
Henneberg, Stephan C., Scammell, Margaret, & O’Shaughnessy, Nicholas J.
(2009). Political marketing management and theories of democracy.
Marketing Theory, 9(2), 165188.
Ismail, Faisal. (2011). The nahdlatul ulama: Its early history and contribution to
the establishment of Indonesian State. Journal of Indonesian Islam, 5(2),
247282.
Manovich, Lev. (2003). New media from Borges to HTML. The New Media
Reader, 1(2), 1325.
Miller, Peggy J., Hengst, Julie A., & Wang, Su hua. (2003). Ethnographic
methods: Applications from developmental cultural psychology.
Newman, Bruce I. (1994). The marketing of the president: Political marketing as
campaign strategy. Sage.
Patel, Keshav, & Binjola, Himani. (2020). Tik Tok the New Alternative Media for
Youngsters for Online Sharing of Talent: An Analytical Study. Available at
SSRN 3600119.
Rafiq, Mohammed, & Ahmed, Pervaiz K. (2000). Advances in the internal
marketing concept: definition, synthesis and extension. Journal of Services
Marketing.
Rowe, Rebecca, & SHRM-CPWinona Area, SHRM. (2021). President’s Notes.
Schwanholz, Julia, Graham, Todd, & Stoll, Peter Tobias. (2018). Managing
Democracy in the Digital Age. Springer.
Rachmat Hidayat/ JOSR: Journal of Social Research, 1(2), 138-150
Spreading The Charm Of 'Feelings Of The Presidential Election' Through
Tiktok Ahead Of The Nahdlatul Ulama Congress 149
Semiawan, Conny R. (2010). Metode penelitian kualitatif. Grasindo.
Turmudi, Endang. (2006). Struggling for the Umma: changing leadership roles of
kiai in Jombang, East Java. ANU Press.
Winter, Glyn. (2000). A comparative discussion of the notion of validity in
qualitative and quantitative research. The Qualitative Report, 4(3), 114.
© 2021 by the authors. Submitted for possible open access publication under
the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY SA)
license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/).